Review: ‘Shazam! The Golden Age of the World’s Mightiest Mortal’

Robert Greenberger

Robert Greenberger is best known to comics fans as the editor of Who's Who In The DC Universe, Suicide Squad, and Doom Patrol. He's written and edited several Star Trek novels and is the author of The Essential Batman Encyclopedia. He's known for his work as an editor for Comics Scene, Starlog, and Weekly World News, as well as holding executive positions at both Marvel Comics and DC Comics.

You may also like...

12 Responses

  1. Brandon Barrows says:

    This sounds terrific. It’s always bothered me that so many sadly unenlightened fans see Captain Marvel as a pale imitation of Superman when, really, it’s the opposite in many regards.

  2. Brandon Barrows says:

    This sounds terrific. It's always bothered me that so many sadly unenlightened fans see Captain Marvel as a pale imitation of Superman when, really, it's the opposite in many regards.

  3. Rick Keating says:

    As a long-time fan of the “Big Red Cheese”, when I saw this book on the shelf at Borders, I took it down and began to thumb through it. Almost immediately I decided I’d buy it.

    But one thing gave me pause. The back cover copy continually refers to Captain Marvel as “Shazam.” Wrong. Shazam was the wizard whose name Billy Batson spoke to become Captain Marvel. At least Captain Marvel was correctly named in the book itself, but those errors on the back cover should’ve been caught in the editing process. In fact, the words “Captain Marvel” don’t even appear on the back cover.

    I did buy the book (because, as I said, Captain Marvel was correctly named within its pages), but I could just as easily have put it back on the shelf because of the incorrect information on the back cover.

    Rick

    • mike weber says:

      Perhaps a trademark issue?

      • Brandon Barrows says:

        Correct. Marvel has owned the trademark to the name “Captain Marvel” since something like 1968, and keeping it is why they trot out some crappy Captain Marvelesque character every few years *cough*Monica Rambeau*cough*. (PAD’s Genis-Vell was awesome, though so I guess it’s not such a bad thing overall.)

        90% of people call him Shazam, anyway.

        • Rick Keating says:

          Partially correct.

          Marvel grabbed the rights to use “Captain Marvel” as the title of a comic, not the rights to the exclusive use of the name for a character. Thus, DC’s various ongoing books or mini-series about the “Big Red Cheese” has included the word “Shazam” in the title; but within those books (and anywhere else he appears in the DC universe), Billy Batson’s superhero persona is still called Captain Marvel.

          Plus, as I said, throughout this book the character is repeatedly and correctly identified as Captain Marvel. It’s only on the back cover copy that he’s incorrectly called “Shazam.” There’s no reason why the back cover copy couldn’t have said “When Billy Batson says the magic word ‘Shazam!” he is transformed into Captain Marvel, the World’s Mightiest Mortal….” That would not have crossed any legal lines with Marvel Comics.

          Now, if the book had been called Captain Marvel: The Golden Age of the World’s Mightiest Mortal, Marvel Comics could have taken exception to that. Again, Marvel has the right to “Captain Marvel” as a title, not exclusive rights to the name for a character.

          90 percent call him “Shazam”? Sounds a bit like hyperbole to me. But even if that’s accurate, that doesn’t excuse the inaccurate information on the back cover by the writers and/or editors who should know better.

          Rick

          • Delmo Walters Jr. says:

            I wish DC & Marvel would come to an agreement over the use of Captain Marvel, maybe share it the way they share “Super Heroes”. I would hate it if a CM movie finally gets made yet is called “Shazam!”. What bothers me is that nowadays most non-comic fans think Dave Chappelle coined the term.

  4. Rick Keating says:

    As a long-time fan of the "Big Red Cheese", when I saw this book on the shelf at Borders, I took it down and began to thumb through it. Almost immediately I decided I'd buy it.But one thing gave me pause. The back cover copy continually refers to Captain Marvel as "Shazam." Wrong. Shazam was the wizard whose name Billy Batson spoke to become Captain Marvel. At least Captain Marvel was correctly named in the book itself, but those errors on the back cover should've been caught in the editing process. In fact, the words "Captain Marvel" don't even appear on the back cover.I did buy the book (because, as I said, Captain Marvel was correctly named within its pages), but I could just as easily have put it back on the shelf because of the incorrect information on the back cover.Rick

    • mike weber says:

      Perhaps a trademark issue?

      • Brandon Barrows says:

        Correct. Marvel has owned the trademark to the name "Captain Marvel" since something like 1968, and keeping it is why they trot out some crappy Captain Marvelesque character every few years *cough*Monica Rambeau*cough*. (PAD's Genis-Vell was awesome, though so I guess it's not such a bad thing overall.)90% of people call him Shazam, anyway.

        • Rick Keating says:

          Partially correct.Marvel grabbed the rights to use "Captain Marvel" as the title of a comic, not the rights to the exclusive use of the name for a character. Thus, DC's various ongoing books or mini-series about the "Big Red Cheese" has included the word "Shazam" in the title; but within those books (and anywhere else he appears in the DC universe), Billy Batson's superhero persona is still called Captain Marvel.Plus, as I said, throughout this book the character is repeatedly and correctly identified as Captain Marvel. It's only on the back cover copy that he's incorrectly called "Shazam." There's no reason why the back cover copy couldn't have said "When Billy Batson says the magic word 'Shazam!" he is transformed into Captain Marvel, the World's Mightiest Mortal…." That would not have crossed any legal lines with Marvel Comics.Now, if the book had been called Captain Marvel: The Golden Age of the World's Mightiest Mortal, Marvel Comics could have taken exception to that. Again, Marvel has the right to "Captain Marvel" as a title, not exclusive rights to the name for a character.90 percent call him "Shazam"? Sounds a bit like hyperbole to me. But even if that's accurate, that doesn't excuse the inaccurate information on the back cover by the writers and/or editors who should know better.Rick

          • Delmo Walters Jr. says:

            I wish DC & Marvel would come to an agreement over the use of Captain Marvel, maybe share it the way they share "Super Heroes". I would hate it if a CM movie finally gets made yet is called "Shazam!". What bothers me is that nowadays most non-comic fans think Dave Chappelle coined the term.