Review: Spain Rodriguez’ ‘Che: A Graphic Biography’
“Spain” Rodriquez and “Che” Guevara. Manuel and Ernesto. Two legends, one living, the other, well, not so much.
Spain has been a cartoonist for more than 40 years, one of the first and most visible and influential storytellers of the underground comix movement. While others were preoccupied (often brilliantly) with their X-rated tributes to Harvey Kurtzman, Max Fleischer and other visionaries of their childhood, Spain was telling adventure stories of urban America, often featuring his character Trashman. His works have a strong left-wing tilt. He continues to be active, contributing to [[[American Splendor]]], Blab! and [[[Tikkun]]], and he produced the highly acclaimed graphic novel [[[Nightmare Alley]]] for Fantagraphics. He’s been fairly active in recent years on the comics convention circuit, often appearing with S. Clay Wilson.
Che was a handsome medical doctor (specializing in leprosy) and revolutionary, part of the insurgency force that overthrew the Cuban puppet dictator Fulgencio Batista and his American mobster masters, Lucky Luciano and Meyer Lansky. When, in 1967, he was killed as he was organizing in Bolivia, Che became more than a mere martyr: he became an icon. Today, his likeness (inspired by Jim Fitzpartick’s classic illustration) is well-merchandised by capitalist clothing manufacturers in America. He even had floor space at the New York Licensing Show a couple years ago.
It was only a matter of time before Spain turned his professional attentions to Che. Actually, I’m surprised it took this long.
If you’re one of those people who reduce Dr. Guevara’s work down to that of an evil godless Commie, then this graphic novel is the exact right thing for you, as long as your life insurance is paid up. If you think the left might have had legitimate cause for their actions, you’ll like this as well. If you’re open-minded and curious about the events immediately to America’s south during the 1950s and 1960s that had such an overwhelming impact on our society and our political system, then this book is essential.
On the other hand, if you’re a fan of the comic art form and are curious as to how such a powerful biography can be told in this medium, then Spain Rodriguez’ [[[Che: A Graphic Biography]]] is absolutely critical. Yeah, it’s a bit didactic in places – Spain’s got a point of view and he’s going to share it, but it never takes over the story. Indeed, he’s quite open about the Castros’ shutting down critical newspapers and disenfranchisement of political moderates.
Che suffers from some unfortunate production issues. The lettering is overly pixilated and overall there’s a slightly fuzzy look to the material. It’s minor, but it was avoidable and the material deserved better treatment.
If this graphic biography inspires you to Google around a bit and study up, then I smile upon you and Spain alike, pleased that you both have accomplished your mission.
Che: A Graphic Biography
Written and drawn by Spain Rodriguez.
“Indeed, he’s quite open about the Castros’ shutting down critical newspapers and disenfranchisement of political moderates.”
Mike, Castro and Che KILLED people. And not just soldiers in a war, unarmed people whose “crime” was to not be 100% on board with the new bloodthirsty boss, same as the old bloodthirsty boss.(“If any person has a good word for the previous government that is good enough for me to have him shot.”) Reducing their savagery to “disenfranchisement ” does not fill me with hope of this being any more useful than a potential Walter Duranty hagiography on Stalin or a hard hitting expose of Franco by Pat Buchanan.
It may still be worthwhile from an artistic standpoint, of course.
Che was just another probable sociopath who lucked out in living in a place and era that allowed him to indulge his predilection for violence…and even luckier in that he had a nice picture taken of him, though that ended up being something that only capitalists profited from. Which is amusing on several levels. I regard anyone wearing a (non-ironic) Che T-shirt as I would someone who has a Mao poster or a painting by John Wayne Gacy. They either don;t know any better or they are trying to be edgy. The alternative explanation is too scary.
(Frankly, I think the National Lampoon “Che Guevara’s Bolivian Diaries” by the late great Doug Kenney does the best job of truly capturing the earnest incompetence of Che’s final, most conclusive, failure.)