Comments (2)

Add a CommentInappropriate or promotional comments may be removed.

Reply
mike weber (8:11 PM on Fri Aug 29, 2008)

"Watchmen" did not win the "Best Novel" Hugo. John (Guidry) and Justin (Winston) declared - among the many bad decisions they made - declared that it was not eligible. (When i asked John why not, he said "It's a comic book" I pointed out that it met the Higo Rules definition of a novel, and John said "It's a comicbook")

A "Best Other Forms" Hugo was created, specifically to give a Hugo to "Watchmen" (though i don't know if any of the NOLaCon people would admit it).

I consider John & Justin friends, but they were *so* wrong about almost everything they did in 1988...

Reply
Kevin Standlee (11:44 PM on Fri Aug 29, 2008)

As Mike Webber said, Watchmen did not win the 1988 Hugo Award for Best Novel. (That was won by David Brin's The Uplift War. As you can see by the official results, it won an award in a special category for Other Form added using the same Additional Category rule that Anticipation is using to add Best Graphic Story to the 2009 Hugo Award ballot.

Incidentally, for the past few years, works such as Watchmen were eligible -- but in Best Related Book, rather than in one of the written-fiction categories. Shaun Tan's graphic novel The Arrival was nominated in this category this year, for instance.

I wrote about the proposal to add Best Graphic Story as a permanent category in more detail on my LiveJournal.

Add a comment

Inappropriate or promotional comments may be removed. To create a clickable link, simply type the URL (including http://) and we will make a link for you. Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted — no need to use <p> or <br> tags, but if you're into that kind of thing, you can use any of the following tags: b, i, strong, em, a (href only), p and br.

Click one of the three commenter types below. Member comments are added immediately once you confirm your email address. Anonymous comments are moderated by our editorial staff.

Email me

  

Comment Preview
Avatar
Anonymous (3:52 AM on Sat Nov 21, 2009)

Preview your comment here.

Read our comics -- for free!


Active Conversations

ComicMix Features

Articles by contributor

ComicMix Podcasts

this gets replaced with a player
Κ ΚΚΚΚ ΚΚΚΚ