Comments (10)

Add a CommentInappropriate or promotional comments may be removed.

Reply
Alan Coil (1:25 PM on Fri Nov 2, 2007)

Dear Dumb,

Lemme axe ya sumpin: A test is designed using the English language, based on the lives, experiences, and education of a Euro-centric people, then you give the test to all people. Then when the results "prove" that Euro-centric people are smarter, you claim it's because they are white? Idiot.
-----
Thanks for bringing up this subject, Michael. This is the first I heard of this episode. I am ashamed of the news stations I listen to and the online sites I read. None of them have yet to mention this. I listen (or read) to local news, national news, cbs overnight news, yahoo, huffingtonpost, raw story, and even 2 different liberal radio stations from the Detroit area. None of them have covered this.

Reply
Marilee J. Layman (4:29 PM on Fri Nov 2, 2007)

Here's what the WashPost wrote about it. I heard it on local and national TV news. It was widely discussed in the blogs I read.

Reply
Michael Davis (3:00 PM on Fri Nov 2, 2007)

I noticed it did not have wide news coverage in the states. I was out of the country and read this.

Reply
Marilee J. Layman (4:32 PM on Fri Nov 2, 2007)

I just have to note the ads on this article: Stupid People (Fashion Horror Story), The Stupid People Test, James Watson, and Comic Collector.

Reply
Marilee J. Layman (4:40 PM on Fri Nov 2, 2007)

Michael, I absolutely have to agree with you that Watson is wrong about blacks being genetically more stupid than whites. I suspect this is his personal belief, not any kind of science.

However, as someone who still tests with "genius" IQ after a big stroke and coma, I have to tell you that it's entirely possible to be really intelligent and still do and say really stupid things. Intelligence is not permeating; it has holes.

Reply
Michael Davis (4:44 PM on Fri Nov 2, 2007)

Oh, Don't I ever know that Marilee!!

Reply
Michael H. Price (12:00 PM on Mon Nov 5, 2007)

A fascinating presentation, Michael. Dr. James D. Watson (and what might that middle initial signify, other than the christened Dewey?) appears to have parted ways with the Human Genome Project long before it had pointed inexorably to the conclusion that the essential components of humankind are identical, across the board. Some of us have known, or sensed, as much, all along. An intriguing discussion of these findings occurs in Nick Tosches' book WHERE DEAD VOICES GATHER (2001) -- itself a brilliantly digressive inquiry into the tangled roots of American music.

Tempting to wonder whether this particular Doc Watson (!) may have seen a few too many Southern minstrel shows without grasping their larger context of reciprocal satire. The great peril of egghead-ism lies in the risk of mistaking one's biases for empirical data.

Reply
Mike Gold (1:58 PM on Mon Nov 5, 2007)

"seen a few too many Southern minstrel shows without grasping their larger context of reciprocal satire" – that's a great line, MHP.

Reply
Michael H. Price (2:42 PM on Mon Nov 5, 2007)

Aw, shucks, Mike. Main point, here, being to acknowledge the depth of wit and insight that Michael Davis brings to his interpretive account of an under-reported story. I was just about to write back, anyhow, with a couple of quotations that might be relevant.

On our first meeting in 1988 as he was about to emerge from an unwanted retirement, the singer and comedian Rudy Ray "Dolemite" Moore and I veered off onto a tangent that yielded this observation from Mr. Moore: “You want to know what racism is? It’s the belief that there even is any such of a thing as race, to begin with ... [If] you believe that you, or anybody else, must belong to any sub-races within the human race—well, why, then, you’re a racist.” No stranger to declarations of absolutism, Mr. Dolemite.

Later and elsewhere, a musician pal named Ozell "Larry" Reynolds came through with this one: “What happened to divide us all so bad as a society was that we got so all caught up in desegregating — that we forgot to integrate.”

I've always found life amongst working musicians to be so naturally integrated -- culturally, economically, and so forth -- that I want to assume the same of society-at-large. And just when Big Science seems poised to help bring us closer together, here comes a know-it-all Dr. Dumb Ass with a polarizing ramrod. At least, a lot of folks seem not to take this Watson bozo seriously.

Reply
janne (1:01 PM on Fri Nov 16, 2007)

They said Albert Einstein was senile too.

Add a comment

Inappropriate or promotional comments may be removed. To create a clickable link, simply type the URL (including http://) and we will make a link for you. Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted — no need to use <p> or <br> tags, but if you're into that kind of thing, you can use any of the following tags: b, i, strong, em, a (href only), p and br.

Click one of the three commenter types below. Member comments are added immediately once you confirm your email address. Anonymous comments are moderated by our editorial staff.

Email me

  

Comment Preview
Avatar
Anonymous (3:12 PM on Sat Nov 21, 2009)

Preview your comment here.

Read our comics -- for free!


Active Conversations

ComicMix Features

Articles by contributor

ComicMix Podcasts

this gets replaced with a player